Science fair research papers, however, have become a capstone to any successful science fair project. Science fair winners know how to write reports that prove scientific skills and impress the judges, writes science columnist and educator Dr.
Search Share A good peer review requires disciplinary expertise, a keen and critical eye, and a diplomatic and constructive approach.
Writing a good review requires expertise in the field, an intimate knowledge of research methods, a critical mind, the ability to give fair and constructive feedback, and sensitivity to the feelings of authors on the receiving end. As a range of institutions and organizations around the world celebrate the essential role of peer review in upholding the quality of published research this week, Science Careers shares collected insights and advice about how to review papers from researchers across the spectrum.
The responses have been edited for clarity and brevity. What do you consider when deciding whether to accept an invitation to review a paper? I consider four factors: I see it as a tit-for-tat duty: Since I am an active researcher and I submit papers, hoping for really helpful, constructive comments, it just makes sense that I do the same for others.
The only other factor I pay attention to is the scientific integrity of the journal.
I would not want to review for a journal that does not offer an unbiased review process. For every manuscript of my own that I submit to a journal, I review at least a few papers, so I give back to the system plenty. Finally, I am more inclined to review for journals with double-blind reviewing practices and journals that are run by academic societies, because those are both things that I want to support and encourage.
I will turn down requests if the paper is too far removed from my own research areas, since I may not be able to provide an informed review. Having said that, I tend to define my expertise fairly broadly for reviewing purposes.
I also consider the journal.
I am more willing to review for journals that I read or publish in. Before I became an editor, I used to be fairly eclectic in the journals I reviewed for, but now I tend to be more discerning, since my editing duties take up much of my reviewing time.
Some journals have structured review criteria; others just ask for general and specific comments. Knowing this in advance helps save time later. I almost never print out papers for review; I prefer to work with the electronic version.
I always read the paper sequentially, from start to finish, making comments on the PDF as I go along. I look for specific indicators of research quality, asking myself questions such as: Are the background literature and study rationale clearly articulated?
Do the hypotheses follow logically from previous work? Are the methods robust and well controlled? Are the reported analyses appropriate?
I usually pay close attention to the use—and misuse—of frequentist statistics. Is the presentation of results clear and accessible?Quality academic help from professional paper & essay writing service.
Best team of research writers makes best orders for students. Bulletproof company that guarantees customer support & lowest prices & money back. Place with timely delivery and free revisions that suit your needs! Hundreds of detailed science fair project ideas for all grade levels in a wide range of topics from Aerodynamics to Zoology.
Welcome! This is the official web site for the Illinois Junior Academy of Science Region 11 Science Fair. The fair is organized by the Joliet Diocese Science Teachers Association (JDSTA). The JDSTA Region 11 Science Fair gives students a valuable learning experience.
Paper Towel Science Fair Project. How to test the absorbency rate of different brands of paper towels. Science fair research papers are written in the form format that you may use to write a science project report.
If your project includes people, animals, regulated substances, or hazardous materials, you can attach an appendix that includes special activities you needed to do for your project. Ideas for future research. Some science fairs want you to discuss what additional research you might want to do based on what you learned.
For a Good Science Fair Project Final Report, You Should Answer "Yes" to Every Question Background research (your Research Paper).